Arthur wasn't planned until the development of rdr2. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. No, he's better as a new character in rdr2. EDIT: To all the people saying Arthur wasnt created until RDR2, thats why, you're missing the point. Ive spent a lot of time at the ranch with the Marston Family. This little scene took place today at Beechers Hope. What Did John Do With Arthur'S Hat? - Bliss Tulle Any mention of Arthur in RDR1? (end game spoilers) 2. In Red Dead Redemption 2, Arthur Morgan can swim as long as his stamina holds out, which is a fairly long time. Especially since even then, he doesn't like talking about his past, let alone dwell on the details. He didn't get mentioned the same way Saddie wasn't mentioned, or the native american dude, or Micah Bell, Pearson, Lenny, Joshua, Karen, etc My point is: There's no particular reason for him not being mentioned. in his new life as a Blackwater bank accountant, that would give him away, like what happened to Michael in GTAV. Because his character was probably created after RDR1 was completed. Only one I remember from rdr1 was bill and Dutch. The games vast and atmospheric world will also provide the foundation for a brand new online multiplayer experience. Wild Mint is extremely common to find near streams, marshes and moist meadows all over the map. The point is, the writers didnt lazily ignore the fact that John didnt mention Arthur in RDR1. Dutch will leave if the player was honorable because he cant choose between them. Arthur gave them the money to flee and start over, which turned out to be money wasted because their new life prospecting in the Tundra failed. He has pleaded not guilty. Said it in General but I'll post it again here-, Well John does vaguely allude to other gang members in RDR. Currently Playing: SRTT, Forza 4, Kingdoms of Amalur, AOT:TDC, also if you dont want spoilers DONT look up help with any of the Hunts or Collectibles. Why has this Georgia man been behind bars for 10 years awaiting trial? Red Dead Redemption 2; All Activity; Home ; Red Dead ; Red Dead Redemption 2 [Speculation Topic] Why Arthur is not mentioned in RDR1? I go back to the living room and *greet* Abigail, who is still sewing on the sofa), JOHN: (irritated) Why would you say that?, ABIGAIL: (awkward) Its true, aint it?, JOHN: (difficult) Look I can talk about him it just hurts is all., I think the reason (at least the story reason) that John doesnt talk about Arthur in RDR1 is because he misses him like a brother, but also because hes kinda ashamed of the fact that Arthur saved his ass on more than one occasion, and ultimately saved his wife and son. No looking back., (Jack gets up and walks out. Even in 1907, hes barely mentioned at all, so history forgot about him. Is Arthur referenced in rdr1? Ive finished the game twice now, and I want to share my thoughts. Karen Jones. [Speculation Topic] Why Arthur is not mentioned in RDR1? 2023 GAMESPOT, A FANDOM COMPANY. This part of my theory is based largely two key things: That there are different timelines presented in the Red Dead story, and that one of these timelines is packed with supernatural elements while the other is mostly mundane. off topic, but correct me if im wrong, was landon ricketts a outlaw before he came a vigilante ? I mean, they couldn't have mentioned him- since they didnt have rdr2 planned when they made rdr1. RubyLane is an internet site. (Looks at me) Do you, John?, JOHN: (pause) No. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. the government did a similar thing with marston and blackmailed them to do certain things for them. TL;DR In RDR1, John doesnt mention Arthur because 1) it hurts him to think of him, 2) hes ashamed that Arthur saved his family, and 3) he said not to look back. Any theories? Morgan isn't low level, pretty sure he's even Dutch's right hand man. TL;DR - John doesnt mention Arthur in RDR1 because 1) It hurts him to think of Arthur, 2) Hes ashamed that Arthur saved his family, 3) Arthur said to not look back. For me with arthur not being mentioned to me is because I think john just didnt like talking about him. Mr Van der Linde - Chapter 6 - dutchvanwinkle - Red Dead Redemption Content posted in this community. I found that to be reason enough. If you decide to kill him, Arthur will choke him and leave him in the barn. It could also be argued that Red Dead Revolver takes place in a similar but alternate reality from RDR1. ^ Yeah, thats very basically right. He he saved us!, ABIGAIL: Well, yes. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. How do I take cover by the door while trying to save Javier in chapter 5? To be honest, despite the screens we've seen of John so far, it could be possibility that he and Morgan won't actually interact that much. Here are the best content by the team thcsnguyenthanhson.edu.vn synthesize and compile, see more in the section How. Do you think they should've mentioned Arthur on rdr1? Little moments like the one above are worth discussing. Bill and Javier didnt get the focus and screen-time they deserved in RDR 2. You gotta run and don't look back. I (John) walk in and join them. P.S: of course we know that they didn't think on this new . In RDR1, Arthur is never mentioned by name; rather, John has a conversation with Bonnie early on in which he says something about how a friend helped him avoid the gang life..Does Jack Remember Arthur? Can you upgrade satchel after Arthur dies? - TimesMojo Howler 4 years ago #8. why is arthur not mentioned in rdr1. Cookie Notice In rdr1, Arthur Morgan was never mentioned. They were basically brothers. Oct 25, 2017 RDR1 was about Marston beyotching the whole game about those who did him wrong. I came up with a theory on what would happen if Mr. Downes didn't spit on our Boah., I just finished Far Cry 5 and my only question is Why? He is well aware of what he did for him. It's part of what makes this such a good game, that famous attention to detail. bubble tea consumption statistics australia. Its worth discussing. UltraGizmo64 and. Arthurs last dying efforts (in my playthrough) were to save the Marstons, and among his last words were to not look back.. P.S: of course we know that they didn't think on this new character when they created RDR1, but let's theorize just based on the storyline's perspective and not the limitations or the guessing that R* had back in 2010 vs now. They addressed it through story and character in many subtle ways to discover, rather than a single throwaway line. If Redemption 1 had been Redemption 2, then yes. Why is so necessary to treat your players like lazy morons? Required fields are marked *. He tells people that he was in a gang with Dutch, Bill and Javier, they left him for dead in a botched robbery and he left the gang. Arthur has no doubts about everything, every plan, every idea, and every person because that is who he is. It seems more likely to me given the fact that we see the world of RDR2 populated with aliens, time travelers and ghosts that John never mentions Arthur, Hosea, Sadie or Micah ever in RDR1 because they never existed in RDR1 John's timeline than because he forgot or just didn't like talking about it. they all died. He isn't as devoted to his family, and he struggles to deal with the gang's . A good ole fashion gunfight in the street, where the game uses a specific system to quick draw on an enemy, whom starts a gunfight in the street or at cards with you. Comment *document.getElementById("comment").setAttribute("id","a9662a6c7cffb085762f3b1d1f5f3454");document.getElementById("b7ae61571b").setAttribute("id","comment"); Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Could Arthur Morgan have survived TB? - Rankiing.net rdr2 agarita locations map Companion theory: RDR2 and Undead Nightmare take place in the same timeline, separate from RDR1. in his new life as a Blackwater band accountant, that would give him away, like what happened to Michael in GTAV. The south side of any house will receive, The direction from which wind blows (such as the north wind) is named after it. Home; Service. 22 How To Rob Bank Rdr2 Ultimate Guide 04/2023 Of course, the IRL reason is that Arthur wasn't created until RDR2. Even in 1907, he's barely mentioned at all, so history forgot about him. Plus, based on John's dealings in RDR with the remaining old gang members, generally didn't go so well. [Speculation Topic] Why Arthur is not mentioned in RDR1? May 9, 2018 in Red Dead Redemption 2. Ive completed the main story and epilogue for RDR2 months ago, and have been playing the Endless Summer nightly ever since (when Im not online). So, they probably weren't expecting to return to it. As it says the title, let's speculate why Arthur is not even mentioned in Red Dead Redemption 1 by John Marston, as far we know now, Arthur is the enforcer and like "the big brother" that looks after the gang, why in the original RDR (based 12 years later) is like he never existed? However, as John, I have been all over that area bounty hunting and animal hunting, so his aforementioned statement doesn't seem true. TL;DR - John doesn't mention Arthur in RDR1 because 1) It hurts him to think of Arthur, 2) He's ashamed that Arthur saved his family, 3) Arthur said to not look back. Abigail is sewing while Jack reads a book. i agree with what others said. rdr2 pc teleport mod You are reading about how to rob bank rdr2. Rockstar tying up loose ends SHAREfactoryhttps://store.playstation.com/#!/en-us/tid=CUSA00572_00 But if they could've had the foresight, yeah- it might've been better to mention him just a little. Best Work Writer's Discussion 2016 [The "I Love Karen Daniels" fanfic]. how do you make wheel in little alchemy; what does miss honey describe as her greatest triumph Open menu. Do Red Dead 1 and 2 have the same map? - Arthur not being mentioned at all in RDR1 and the original Dutch gang being comprised of four main members are major plot inconsistencies for both games. But, I don't see how it could have been. Your email address will not be published. All Rights Reserved. Not all the new gang members need to die in RDR II. Cheap GTA 5 Shark Cards & More Games: https://www.g2a.com/r/mrbos. MARKUS. Maybe the gang would've survive if he wasn't sick?. BY: Phillip Tinner . Right before Morgan's death at the end, choking and sputtering in Marston's arms, he'll say to John with his final words: "Promise me, John don't mention me, don't think about me, don't even acknowledge my previous existence at any point in time. why is arthur not mentioned in rdr1 DarrenC1888, Why do they never mention Arthur Morgan in RDR1? It's because he doesn't exist in RDR1's timeline. JACK: (remembering) Arthur! My speculation is that when John Is shot, Arthur Tried to save him but he couldn't somehow. Devs didn't think of him back then. why is arthur not mentioned in rdr1. Aside from that, why is Arthur not mentioned in rdr1? "Nobody talks about it," Holmes said. That something is redemption for all of his gang members, and Arthur is his most important. By If RDR 1 did have any references to RDR 2, realistically speaking, Arthur wouldnt actually be a likely choice. The most popular theory is that Krall was a Gorn, a lizard-like alien species that Kirk and the Enterprise crew defeated in the original Star, Where should I go to sell my Hummel figurines? This means that a north wind blows from the north,, Anything goes with stone, black, white, coral, aqua, any shade of blue, baby pink, hot pink, emerald green, olive green, and red.